← The archive
Episode No.182

Let’s Scare Jessica to Death (1971)

Directed by John D. Hancock. Starring Zohra Lampert, Barton Heyman, Kevin O'Connor, Gretchen Corbett.

Horror
Let’s Scare Jessica to Death

9 September 2025 · 1:05:11

John D. Hancock’s Let’s Scare Jessica to Death (1971) is a moody, low-budget psychological horror shot in Connecticut, emerging at the uneasy dawn of the 1970s when American genre cinema was shifting toward ambiguity and dread rather than monsters and gore. Starring Zohra Lampert as the fragile Jessica, supported by Barton Heyman and Mariclare Costello, the film follows a small group retreating to a rural farmhouse where whispers of the past mingle with Jessica’s precarious mental state. Should this eerie curio languish in obscurity like a ghost no one believes in, or should it be acknowledged as a living, breathing classic of psychological horror?

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

A double blind, picked up in Vinegar Syndrome's new 4K restoration. The title had Dan braced for video-nasty exploitation. It turned out to be nothing of the sort.

Jessica (Zohra Lampert), six months out of a psychiatric hospital, moves to a remote farmhouse on an island with her husband Duncan (Barton Heyman) and their friend Woody (Kevin O'Connor). They arrive in a hearse with LOVE painted on the side, and a double bass case that looks like a coffin. The locals, all old men with bandages, are hostile, and a drifter called Emily (Mariclare Costello), found living in the house, bears an uncanny resemblance to a girl who drowned in the cove a century earlier. Jessica keeps hearing whispers and telling herself not to mention them, because nobody will believe her.

Hancock was reportedly offered a parody script about something that drinks hippie blood and agreed only if he could make it serious, with The Haunting and Repulsion as his models. Made for around $250,000, it trades gore for atmosphere: mist on the water, a girl in white who appears and vanishes, a seance, an apple orchard with poison on the fruit. Shot as the Manson trial was under way, it reads as an elegy for the hippie dream, which is curdling into something predatory. Orville Stoeber's songs share the soundtrack with Walter Sear's strange analogue synths, which Dan loved. Then the finale piles on the horror, with a few moments Friday the 13th would later borrow. Hancock went on to be fired from Jaws 2.

Conrad was riveted from start to finish. Dan admired the craft, found it slow and the whispered narration grating, and threw it back. The patrons broke the tie and set it free.

  • But did I enjoy it? I'm not sure whether I did. I don't know whether I would recommend it. But I can see how it's influential. So I'm going to have to say I'll throw it back in.
    Dan
  • If you love this type of haunting country house in the middle of nowhere movie, this is an undiscovered gem that you may not have heard of.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.