In the Mouth of Madness (1994)
Directed by John CarpenterRegular. Starring Sam NeillRegular, Julie Carmen, Jürgen Prochnow, David Warner.

Dan and Conrad tear up some paperback covers and assemble a map to John Carpenter's "last good film", 1994's 'In the Mouth of Madness'. It's got Sam Neill, Charlton Heston, a naked old man handcuffed to his wife's ankle, and more Lovecraftian cosmic horror than you could shake a tentacle at. But, crucially, is it actually any good?
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictThrown back
The third and final entry in Carpenter's unofficial Apocalypse Trilogy, after The Thing and Prince of Darkness: an insurance investigator (Sam Neill) is hired to track down a missing horror novelist (Jürgen Prochnow) whose latest bestseller is driving readers insane, only to discover the fictional town where his books are set is bleeding into reality. It's Lovecraft filtered through a Stephen King-shaped pulp novelist, right down to lines lifted almost verbatim from Lovecraft's own prose, and it's built around a properly interesting premise: cosmic horror as a virus spread through mass-market fiction. The practical effects work, tentacled, slime-drenched, constantly mutating, is genuinely well executed for the most part, and a wonderful cast (David Warner, John Glover, Charlton Heston) shows up around Neill even if most of them barely get a scene each.
The problem is everything holding it together. There's atmosphere without dread, ideas without suspense, and a plot that lurches from one striking, unexplained image to the next without ever earning the emotional stakes it's reaching for. Both of us went in expecting more, one of us specifically remembering loving it years ago and finding that fondness didn't survive a rewatch. Worth seeking out if cosmic horror and Lovecraft references are your whole thing; as an actual gripping piece of cinema, it isn't.
There are so many elements of the film that I feel could have worked, but they just don't. It has just been haphazardly stitched together. You never really feel immersed in the story and the characters.
Dan There's no sense of dread, there's no sense of suspense, there's no engagement with the characters. As an apocalyptic tale of terror, I wasn't particularly terrorised or engaged, to be honest.
Conrad
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.


