← The archive
Episode No.115

Elvira: Mistress of the Dark (1988)

Directed by James Signorelli. Starring Cassandra Peterson, W. Morgan Sheppard, Daniel Greene, Susan Kellermann.

Horror
Elvira: Mistress of the Dark

14 November 2022 · 1:05:50

Conrad and Dan are exposed to Elvira for the very first time in this Patreon's Choice episode, and watch with delight as the busty horror movie host scandalises the small, conservative town she visits in search of her past... and the money she needs to fund her Vegas debut. Elvira: Mistress of the Dark (1988) stars Cassandra Peterson as the irrepressible Elvira, E. Morgan Sheppard as her scheming great uncle Vinnie, Daniel Green as the naive town hunk, Bob, and Edie McClurg as the hilariously shrewish Chastity Pariah. It's the kind of comedy they don't make any more, but it that a sad or a good thing? Does Elvira work for a dumbfounded international audience? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Patron Wicked Person's pick off the Oubliette Roulette, and an education for two non-Americans who'd never encountered the horror-host tradition.

Cassandra Peterson's Elvira quits her TV slot after the new station owner gets handsy, needs $50,000 to fund a Vegas show, and heads to the prim Massachusetts town of Fallwell to collect her great-aunt's legacy: a house, a poodle and a recipe book her warlock great-uncle (W. Morgan Sheppard) badly wants. What follows is a fish-out-of-water comedy fired off at machine-gun pace by a cast stuffed with members of the Groundlings improv troupe, all Valley Girl one-liners and double entendres. Conrad put the hit rate at roughly half groans and half genuine laughs, which across this many jokes is still plenty.

Elvira is never the butt of the joke and never needs rescuing, and her hunky, oblivious love interest is a neat inversion of the dumb blonde. The film's shrug at the men who keep groping her has dated badly, the teenagers the studio insisted on are barely characters, and the third-act lurch into fire-breathing witchcraft and a witch burning comes out of nowhere. The crockpot monster is a delight, and the casserole that turns the town's moral majority into libertines is a hoot. It runs long, and its message about being yourself never quite lands. Dan wasn't sure he was the right audience and found plenty of jokes fell flat, but thinks Elvira, a goth, queer and outsider icon in the line from Morticia and Vampira, matters too much to throw back. Conrad laughed throughout. Set free.

  • I don't think I could possibly put this back in the Oubliette. I think it is too important for so many people.
    Dan
  • If you fancy a ridiculous, wacky, sex-positive comedy with a strong female central character that will have you rolling on the floor laughing, go for it. This is your movie.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.