← The archive
Episode No.191

Don't Torture a Duckling (1972)

Directed by Lucio Fulci. Starring Florinda Bolkan, Barbara Bouchet, Tomas Milian, Irene Papas.

Horror
Don't Torture a Duckling

3 February 2026 · 1:16:39

Our second film for this year will also be our second dip of the toe into the filmography of Lucio Fulci (see episode 158 for our take on Conquest, his bonkers fantasy adventure, with our special guest Vincenzo Natali).

Don’t Torture a Duckling (Non si sevizia un paperino, 1972) is remembered as one of the most unsettling and thematically ambitious entries in the Italian giallo cycle. Its premise is deceptively simple: a series of brutal child murders shatters a seemingly idyllic community, prompting an investigation led by journalist Andrea Martelli (Tomas Milian) and local police. Suspicion falls quickly – and tellingly – on society’s outsiders: a reclusive “witch” (Florinda Bolkan), a mentally vulnerable man, and anyone who doesn't conform to the village’s rigid moral order. As the mystery unfolds, the film reveals a gallery of compromised adults whose piety and respectability mask repression, misogyny, and latent violence.

Should Don’t Torture a Duckling be released from the oubliette and re-examined like an uncomfortable truth finally brought to light, or left buried with Maciara's baby? Find out!

Skip the guess and read the review

Our rating

VerdictSet free

Our second giallo and our second Fulci, after Conquest, and another film nothing like the zombie pictures he's known for. A double blind.

Boys are being murdered in a poor southern Italian village, and the locals go looking for someone to blame: the village simpleton Giuseppe, who tried to ransom a boy he'd found dead; Florinda Bolkan's Maciara, the outcast "witch" who sticks pins in wax dolls; and Barbara Bouchet's Patrizia, a bored rich woman exiled from the city after a drugs scandal, who flaunts herself at a priest and, notoriously, at a 12-year-old. Tomas Milian's cynical journalist does the detective work that the police won't.

Fulci swaps the black gloves and chrome of the city giallo for church bells and a lynch mob, a motorway looming above the village as the modern world speeds past. The film keeps shifting its protagonist and throwing red herrings at us. The murders happen off screen, and the one prolonged act of violence is the fathers beating the innocent Maciara with chains, scored with cheerful pop songs on a car radio, before she crawls to the roadside and the holiday traffic ignores her. It's harrowing and unforgettable. Riz Ortolani's score swings from swooning romance to Echoplexed string stabs. Fulci was prosecuted over the Bouchet scene, and the charges were dropped once he showed the boy had been doubled by an adult actor. The killer's fate, intercut with children playing football, is surreal and grisly. The dubbing takes adjusting to.

We both set it free. About two thirds of the patrons wanted it thrown back, and we overruled them.

  • It's a deeply moving movie as well. I did not expect that.
    Dan
  • I think it's a remarkable piece of filmmaking that I was glad to experience. So I'd certainly recommend it to people.
    Conrad

Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.