Basket Case (1981)
Directed by Frank Henenlotter. Starring Kevin Van Hentenryck, Beverly Bonner, Terri Susan Smith, Diana Browne.

The next film to emerge from the Oubliette is Basket Case (1981): the debut feature of Frank Henenlotter, a New York exploitation obsessive who spent his youth in the grindhouses of 42nd Street and, with producer Edgar Ievins, put roughly $35,000 of mostly their own money into turning a title he liked into a film he never expected anyone to see.
Shot on 16mm over about 6 months of spare weeks and weekends, in the last years of Times Square as the Deuce, it follows a wide-eyed young man (Kevin Van Hentenryck) who carries his formerly conjoined and decidedly ill-tempered twin around town in a wicker basket on a revenge tour of the surgeons who split them apart.
It arrived in 1982 amid the slasher boom, with a first distributor keen to trim the blood, before a Texas midnight show, Joe Bob Briggs and a long run at New York's Waverly turned it into a midnight staple and, after a well-timed $19.95 VHS, a fixture of fans' bedrooms. It has since been restored by the Museum of Modern Art, which might be the strangest plot twist in the whole saga. But does the film, which has been on Dan's watchlist since we started the podcast, deserve a place in the world outside the Oubliette? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
It's been on Dan's watch list since we were planning the podcast eight years ago. Finally, a double blind.
Duane Bradley (Kevin Van Hentenryck) checks into a seedy Times Square hotel carrying a large wicker basket. Inside is Belial, his formerly conjoined twin, a snarling lump of head and claws who shares a psychic link with him and a grudge against the three doctors who separated them. Duane feeds him hamburgers and helps him hunt the doctors down, until he meets Sharon (Terri Susan Smith), a receptionist, and Belial doesn't take kindly to sharing.
It was reportedly made for about $35,000 on 16mm over weekends, with furniture fished out of skips. Dick Smith's protégés Kevin Haney and John Caglione did the gore, and the blood looks alarmingly real. The sound is a mess, much of the acting is wooden, the stop-motion is deliberately janky, and a 12-minute flashback stops the film dead halfway through. But it's a priceless record of 42nd Street before the clean-up, shot without permits among real people, and the bond between the brothers, part sibling and part mother and baby, gives it an odd pathos. Belial's attack on Dr Kutter, ending with a face full of scalpels and a scream like an air-raid siren, is a comic highlight. His final assault on Sharon is just ugly. The distributor reportedly cut the gore and it went nowhere. Re-released uncut, it became a midnight-movie staple, and the Museum of Modern Art restored it in 2017.
Conrad was never bored and never quite won over, so he threw it back. Dan loves it more the more he learns about it. The patrons unanimously set it free.
I can say I was never bored.
Conrad It's kind of one of those films, the more you know about it, and the more you watch it, the better it gets.
Dan
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




