2010: The Year We Make Contact
Directed by Peter HyamsRegular. Starring Roy Scheider, John LithgowRegular, Helen Mirren, Bob BalabanRegular.

To mark the film's 40th anniversary, we revisit Peter Hyams' 2010 – a brave follow-up to a literal monolith in science fiction film history. In what was then called a 'belated' rather than a 'legacy' sequel, the film adapts Arthur C. Clarke's novel and features a stellar cast of Roy Scheider, Helen Mirren, John Lithgow, Bob Balaban and, returning from 2001: A Space Odyssey, Keir Dullea and Douglas Rain as Dave Bowman and HAL 9000. Yes, it's full of stars. But it is a worthy follow-up that stands on its own? Or is it a pale imitation and a footnote? Find out!
Did we set it free?
Make your call to reveal our verdict, our star rating out of five and our full review.
Skip the guess and read the review
VerdictSet free
Our fourth Peter Hyams film, and the first we've tackled without a guest, marking its 40th anniversary. Conrad loved it on VHS as the accessible follow-up to the film that baffled him as a child. Dan remembered one scene.
Nine years after Discovery's disastrous mission, Roy Scheider's Heywood Floyd joins a Soviet crew to find out what went wrong with HAL and what the monolith orbiting Jupiter is up to, while back home the Cold War edges towards nuclear exchange. With him are John Lithgow's queasy engineer and Bob Balaban as Chandra, a role Arthur C. Clarke wrote as Indian. Helen Mirren is superb as the Soviet commander, Tanya Kirbuk (almost Kubrick backwards).
It opens with 22 minutes of exposition, and Floyd's reverb-drenched "Dear Caroline" logs explain everything we've just seen. The interplay between characters is the draw: Lithgow's terrifying first spacewalk between the ships, his bond with Elya Baskin's Max, Mirren and Scheider sharing smuggled Kentucky bourbon, and Chandra's tearful farewell to a HAL who accepts his death. Keir Dullea's Bowman returns as an eerie apparition ("Something wonderful"). Richard Edlund's effects and Jupiter, built from Voyager images and a Cray supercomputer, still impress. Look out for Clarke himself feeding pigeons on a bench outside the White House, and for the pet dolphins Floyd's family keeps at home, which Dan considers a cruelty too far. The swarm of early-CGI monoliths doesn't, and Hyams's added "use them together, use them in peace" coda made us both recoil.
It's a mixed bag that holds up. We both set it free, and so did most of the patrons, Jasmine's protests aside.
I think it's a mixed bag, but I think it holds up.
Conrad I think the effects and performances of the actors alone make this a really compelling watch.
Dan
Verdicts are decided with the people who back the show. Patreon supporters get a vote.




